Everton's Relegation Battle: Unpacking the Fallout of the 10-Point Deduction

Table of Contents

Everton’s appeal against 10-point deduction: What you need to know, Everton fans were stunned and outraged when the Premier League announced that the club had been deducted 10 points for breaching financial rules. The decision, made by an independent commission, is the harshest sporting sanction ever imposed on a Premier League club. But what exactly did Everton do wrong, and what are their chances of overturning the penalty? Here are some key facts and questions about the case.

What did Everton do wrong?

The Premier League has a set of rules called the Profit and Sustainability Regulations, which limit how much clubs can lose over three years. The aim is to prevent clubs from overspending and risking their financial stability. The rules also require clubs to submit accurate financial information annually to the league.

Everton admitted they breached the rules by including interest payments on constructing their new £760m stadium at Bramley Moore Dock as ‘add-backs’ in their 2021-22 season accounts. ‘Add-backs’ can be deducted from a club’s losses to reduce spending, such as depreciation or amortization. Everton argued that the interest payments were permissible ‘add-backs’ because they were related to a long-term capital project that would benefit the club.

However, the independent commission disagreed and ruled that the interest payments were not allowable ‘add-backs.’ The commission also rejected Everton’s claim of mitigating factors, such as the loss of a major sponsorship deal due to the Russia-Ukraine war and the impact of the Covid pandemic on the transfer market. The commission found that Everton had breached the rules by £30m and imposed a 10-point deduction as a punishment.

Why was the penalty so severe?

The 10-point deduction is the biggest sporting sanction ever handed out by the Premier League for a breach of financial rules. The previous record was six points, given to Portsmouth in 2010 for going into administration. The commission said that it considered the breach to be “serious” and “deliberate” and that it wanted to send a “strong message” to other clubs that they must comply with the rules.

Everton has not been told how the commission arrived at the figure of 10 points, and they believe that it is disproportionate and unfair. They point out that other clubs have received much lighter penalties for similar or worse breaches of financial rules. For example, Sheffield Wednesday were initially deducted 12 points in 2020 for inflating their income by selling their stadium to their owner, but this was reduced to six points on appeal. Everton also argues that a sporting penalty for an accounting issue is unjust and does not reflect their efforts to cooperate with the Premier League over the past two years.

What are Everton’s chances of winning their appeal?

Everton have until Friday to submit their formal appeal to the Premier League, which a judicial panel will hear before the end of this season. The panel will review the commission’s ruling and decide whether it was fair and reasonable or should be overturned or reduced. The panel will have access to all the evidence and submissions from both sides and can ask questions and seek clarifications.

Everton hopes they can persuade the panel that the commission made errors in its interpretation and application of the rules and did not consider all the relevant factors and circumstances. They will also try to show that the penalty is excessive and disproportionate and does not serve the interests of fairness or justice. Everton will likely cite precedents from other cases where clubs have successfully appealed against sporting sanctions for financial breaches.

However, Everton faces an uphill battle to win their appeal, as they must prove that the commission’s decision was wrong or unreasonable. The panel will not simply re-hear the case or substitute its judgment for that of the commission. The panel will also have to balance Everton’s arguments with the Premier League’s, which will defend its rules and its authority to enforce them. The panel may also consider the wider implications of its ruling for other clubs and the integrity of the competition.

What are the consequences of the penalty for Everton?

The 10-point deduction has plunged Everton into a relegation battle, as they have dropped from 14th to 19th in the table, five points behind 17th-placed Burnley with 16 games left. Everton face a tough run of fixtures in January, including games against Chelsea, Liverpool, Manchester United, and Arsenal. Everton will need to improve their form and results quickly to avoid dropping into the Championship for the first time since 1951.

The penalty also has serious financial implications for Everton, as relegation would mean losing millions of pounds in TV revenue and sponsorship income. Everton may also face legal claims from other clubs who feel Everton’s breach of the rules has unfairly disadvantaged them. For example, Nottingham Forest, Leicester, and Southampton have reportedly threatened to sue Everton for compensation if they are relegated due to Everton’s points deduction.

The penalty also casts a shadow over Everton’s ambitious plans to build their new stadium, which will open in 2024. The stadium is a key part of Everton’s vision to become a top club in England and Europe, generate more income, and attract more fans. However, the stadium project faces challenges due to rising costs, planning delays, and environmental concerns. The penalty may further jeopardize the project by affecting Everton’s ability to secure funding, repay loans, and meet financial obligations.

How have Everton fans reacted to the penalty?

Everton fans have been shocked and angry at the penalty, which they see as unfair and unjustified. They have accused the Premier League of being biased and inconsistent in its application of the rules and having an agenda against Everton. They have also criticized the club’s management and board for failing to prevent the breach and for not being transparent with the fans about the situation.

Everton fans have rallied behind their club and expressed their support and solidarity. They have launched a campaign called ‘Back the Blues’ to show their loyalty and defiance. They have also organized protests and petitions to voice their discontent and demand justice. Everton fans have vowed to stick with their club through thick and thin, fighting for their survival and future.